Bank of Canada preview: Too early for a radical pivot

The Bank of Canada is widely expected to leave the target for the overnight rate at 5% when it meets next week. Policymakers continue to talk of their willingness to “raise the policy rate further if needed”, and inflation does indeed continue to run hotter than the BoC would like, but we see little prospect of any additional policy tightening from here. Instead, the next move is expected to be an interest rate cut, most probably at the April meeting.

The latest BoC Business Outlook Survey reported softening demand and “less favourable business conditions” in the fourth quarter with high interest rates having “negatively impacted a majority of firms”, leading to “most firms” not planning to “add new staff”. Job growth does appear to be cooling and the Canadian economy contracted in the third quarter and is expected to post sub 1% growth for the fourth quarter. Also remember that Canadian mortgage rates will continue to ratchet higher for an increasing number of borrowers as their mortgage rates reset after their fixed period ends. This will intensify the financial pressure on households, dampening both consumer spending and inflationary pressures. Unemployment is also expected to rise given the slowdown in job creation and high immigration and population growth rates.

Given this backdrop, we expect Canadian headline inflation to slow to 2.7% in the first quarter and get down to 2% in the second versus the consensus forecast of 2.6%. As such, we see scope for the BoC to cut rates by 25bp at every meeting from April onwards – 150bp of interest rate cuts versus the consensus prediction and market pricing of 100bp of policy easing.

Markets currently price in 95/100bp of easing by the Bank of Canada this year. As shown in the chart above, the pricing for rate cuts in the US and Canada has followed a very similar path. The implied timing for the first rate cut is also comparable: May for the Fed (March is 50% priced in), June for the BoC (April is 45% priced in). That is despite the communication by the Federal Reserve which has already pivoted (via Dot Plots) to the easing discussion while the BoC officially still retains a tightening bias.

In practice, even if the BoC chooses – as we suspect – to delay a radical dovish pivot and stay a bit more hawkish than the Fed, pricing for the BoC will not diverge too much from that of the Fed. So, the room for a rebound in CAD short-term rates appears more tied to USD rates than BoC communication.

In FX, the story isn’t much different. The Canadian dollar has been a de-facto proxy for US-related sentiment, acting less and less as a traditional commodity currency – that would normally be hit by strong US data – thus outperforming the rest of high-beta G10 FX since the start of the year. The rebound in USD/CAD to 1.35 is in line with a restrengthening of the USD primarily due to risk sentiment, positioning and seasonal factors, rather than a divergence in Fed-BoC policy patterns. In fact, the USD-CAD two-year swap rate gap has widened further in favour of CAD so far in January, from 20bp to 32bp.