Articles
21 March 2023

Rates Spark: Contained contagion risk puts hikes back on the table

Contained contagion risk would allow the European Central Bank to resume its hawkish forward guidance. Things are more complicated for the Fed as hikes are seen as a key part of regional banks’ problems

The path for higher Fed rates in the US gets more complicated

After a wobbly start, it seems markets have reacted positively to the measures taken over the weekend to shore up financial markets from further contagion. In the US, there is a growing consensus that regional banks’ vagaries will result in a degree of credit tightening for the economy but, were market conditions to remain calm until the Fed meeting concluding tomorrow, we would expect the Fed to still be in a position to hike 25bp. This is a big if, however, and the strength and speed of the market reaction to Silicon Valley Bank’s demise is an important warning that contagion risk is real. In that regard, potential plans to extend FDIC protection to deposits above $250,000, as reported by Bloomberg, would help prevent further runs.

Regional banks’ vagaries will result in a degree of credit tightening for the economy

One of the problems is that the Fed will struggle to escape the perception that further hikes would make regional banks’ funding position more difficult, and that cuts would help them. And this is without talking about the unrealised losses on their bond holdings. We fully expect the Fed to draw the distinction between monetary policy and financial stability but whether that distinction holds depends on the amount of stress the system is under. Above a certain level of stress, the system takes precedence, as the preventive extension of dollar swap lines with foreign central banks has shown.

Less contagion risk would put hikes back into yield curves - and flatten them

Source: Refinitiv, ING
Refinitiv, ING

Systemic risk indicators at manageable levels vindicate ECB hikes

In the event, these lines were barely used, which is good news. This suggests that dollar funding conditions for foreign institutions in the jurisdictions covered by the agreement (the European Central Bank and Bank of England are key participants) are not challenging. We draw a similar conclusion looking at other indicators of wholesale money market funding for banks, for example the fact that FRA-OIS spreads did not make new highs after last week’s spike. Taken together, they suggest contagion risk is still at a manageable level, although this does not preclude an increase in funding and capital cost for banks, and so the economy.

Absent market volatility, the ECB would have guided markets towards higher rates

If this remained the case, the perception would be that the ECB in particular will be emboldened to continue its hiking cycle. Many officials came out of the woodwork to reinforce President Christine Lagarde’s message that future decisions will depend on data, including the effect of banking stress on the economy. They could not help adding, and Lagarde added to the chorus that, absent market volatility, the ECB would have guided markets towards higher rates. In light of this message, a few more days of calm would in our view be enough for markets to price back ECB hikes into the curve. We continue to see euro rates as less liable to drop, and so think a further narrowing of USD-EUR rates differentials is in the cards.

Doubts about the Fed's path have brought impaired trading conditions for Treasuries

Source: Refinitiv, ING
Refinitiv, ING

Today’s events and market view

Bond supply today takes the form of 30Y UK gilts, alongside auctions from Germany (5Y) and Finland (5Y/13Y).

The main economic data releases from Europe will be the Zew survey, and construction output. The former might be an opportunity to get an early read on how recent financial market fears have impacted expectations.

US data are mostly housing-related with existing home sales and house prices the highlights.

Rates direction depends more than ever on market sentiment towards banks. The aggressive response by regulators and public authorities in the US and in Switzerland is a reason for optimism. Much hinges on the perception of contagion risk. After the Credit Suisse takeover, one positive is that markets have no ‘next domino’ to focus on. This should allow hikes to be priced out on the yield curve, and bear-flatten them as a result.

Content Disclaimer
This publication has been prepared by ING solely for information purposes irrespective of a particular user's means, financial situation or investment objectives. The information does not constitute investment recommendation, and nor is it investment, legal or tax advice or an offer or solicitation to purchase or sell any financial instrument. Read more