Article27 July 2018Reading time 4 minutes

France: Second-quarter growth disappoints

GDP figures for the second quarter just wiped out any hope of seeing French GDP growth reach 2% again this year. It seems that everything that could go wrong actually did. The causes are known, but the effects were larger than expected. Current indicators are pointing to a stronger second half but full-year growth of 1.8% is about all we can hope for now

In this article

Disappointing quarterly growth in 2Q18


What went wrong?

It generally happens that a plane crash is the consequence of several independent elements which, taken in isolation, would have done little harm, but taken together, they actually bring the aircraft down. The same was true for second quarter GDP growth figures. All that could possibly go wrong, did.

First, despite the fear of trade wars and the slowdown of eurozone demand, exports rebounded in the second quarter by 0.6%. A better performance in the first quarter, but not enough to compensate for the strong rebound in imports. This wiped off 0.4pp from growth in the second quarter.

Domestic demand was affected by higher oil prices (+35% year on year) and weeks of strikes in the transportation sector. Private consumption declined (by 0.1% quarter on quarter) for the first time since 3Q16. It seems that despite very low interest rates, consumers also refrained from buying more houses as investment declined (by 0.1% QoQ) for the first time since mid-2015. This affected total investment growth, which wasn't strongly supported by businesses either. Indeed, corporate investment rebounded less than expected, by 1.1% QoQ after the dismal 0.1% registered in the first quarter, widening the gap with very high capacity utilisation rates (see graph).

Thomson Reuters
Thomson Reuters

Can it get better?

The good news is that when negative shocks all materialise at the same time, the likelihood that things get worse declines. The threat from strikes is low for the third quarter and trade war fears could abate as well following on Jean-Claude Juncker's meeting with Donald Trump in Washington. Unemployment is declining, but it seems that consumers are opting for more savings rather than for more consumption despite the low interest rate context. If we expect a rebound of private consumption in the third quarter (and no, it will not be a World Cup victory effect), it is likely to be temporary as higher oil prices will take time to be digested. In 2018, we do not expect private consumption growth to exceed the very slow 1.1% reached in 2017.

Purchasing intentions are not materialising

Thomson Reuters
Thomson Reuters

Nevertheless, activity indicators remain elevated, order books are at high levels and capacity utilisation would justify another corporate investment rebound. In the real estate market, we also expect higher investment in the coming months as interest rates are low and as surveys in the building sector are more positive than at any time in the last ten years.

It is therefore too soon to label this the end of the cycle, but the slower growth of the first half makes it unlikely that growth could reach 1.8%, let alone the 2.0% forecast so far for 2018. We are therefore still far from the end of the cycle, and the outlook remains supportive for reform. But the countdown has begun…